I saw this article on Mothering.com (which used to be a print magazine, and a fantastic one at that) about time outs and other forms of punishment.
See the article here --
"why I think time outs are as damaging as spanking."
This made me start to think and evaluate what we do with Wesley especially now that he is 2.
At his 18 month appointment, our doctor told me that time outs are the best discipline method suggesting that we put a cheap umbrella stroller in a room (not necessarily in a corner away from us), but that we could belt him in and he wouldn't wriggle out. Punishment time was 1 minute per year -- so 1 minute at 18 months.
I did this for a while but found that Wesley just didn't understand what was going on so I stopped. Once he got to 22 months old, however, we felt he was exhibiting behavior he knew was wrong -- such as hitting and throwing things. So I put one of the dining room chairs in the corner of the room (the way our house is set up its not isolated). When he would hit, I would warn him and the 2nd time he'd go in his "time out chair."
Since Claire's been born, at one point he'd been in his time out chair almost on a daily basis. It became where he would hit me and say, "time out." He wanted it! I said to Matt and we agreed that if he asked for it we wouldn't do it. So the next time it happened and he asked to go in his time out chair I said, "I'm not putting you in your time out chair, I just want you to stop hitting me."
And you know, it worked. I mean he still hits -- he is after all 2 and everything goes in one ear and out the other -- but I didn't have to "punish" him to stop that immediate behavior and I felt less stressed and still in control, I was still getting my message across.
It has been a long time now that I have put Wesley in time out although the chair is still in the corner. And just today, our cat was laying in it and Wesley goes up to him and shoos him down, "das mine time out chair!". Hmmmm... I think I'm going to put in back at the table now.